Keep forgetting I've made a mountain of doilies [two of which were made while I was away] and never got around to posting them. An article linked on Raverly regarding
Dora Ohrenstein's article regarding if there needs to be the introduction of "standards" within crocheting like [using her example] you'd find within music, particular opera.
In a way I get her point to an extent but I think she's stereotyping to make her point. She's trying to state that people are attracted to the more chunky, quicker, thicker "easy" patterns rather then complicated patterns like doilies. I think in a way it's the result of the society in which we live not the fault or a measure of the crocheter. With consumerism and commercialism we've grown into a "have me now" society and mode of being. Therefore "easy" patterns reflect this. But that is not to say this makes the crocheter any less of one, or less talented. Anything that keeps crocheting going and being passed down should be welcomed. I think any introduction of standards would only create a hierarchical system of perhaps those who see their selves as above and beyond a mere scarf or granny square crocheter. A crocheter is a crochet whatever they make.
But that is just my view for what ever it is worth.
However her paragraph regarding doilies made me smile. They seem to be now a somewhat neglected into the era of vintage crocheting rather then something people are seen to still be making;
"Take a good look at any doily you can get at a flea market for $5 and you will see some pretty awesome handiwork. The stitching is usually beautiful, and the design concept -- extraordinary! How did the designers of them come up with these intricate patterning ideas, and know how to keep their circle flat (in the case of round doilies). This is way before computer models! Further, they represent a compendium of historical techniques: motifs, ways to attach them, ways to create all kinds of patterns and figures using stitches"
However, going on to suggest that because we are in a standardless craft;
"doilies, and a lot of other examples of high level crochet, are not given their due, because the expertise that went into them is not valued, nor understood."
Yet you can be a mere novice, a crochet expert or someone that's never touched crochet to value the craft and talent required to make one. Right? Even by dad can see a good bit of crocheting and he wouldn't know how to start! Doilies have been what I really used to teach myself how to crochet on my second amttempt after all the years had passed since making that blanket using my gran's old patterns. I think the challenge of their shapes, patterns and designs made it an appealing challenge. They may be a bit "old fashioned" but i've found them an ideal soft place to display my compact collection upon.
Either way here's my latest batch;
From top left; 'Luzern', 'Paris' [close up] second row from the right; 'Paris', 'Starfish', 'Siena'.
Luzern, Paris and Siena patterns were taken from; The Prettiest Doilies, 1989, while Starfish was taken from Twilleys of Stanford Crochet for your home 1976.